The Pittsburgh Steelers are no strangers to quarterback controversy, and the latest rumor swirling around the franchise is sure to ignite a firestorm among fans. According to a well-connected insider, the Steelers could be eyeing a high-profile Ohio State quarterback as their next franchise leader. But would this move make Pittsburgh a Super Bowl contender—or set the team back even further?

Steelers’ Quarterback Struggles: A Desperate Search for Stability

The Steelers have been in quarterback purgatory since the retirement of Ben Roethlisberger. While Kenny Pickett was drafted in the first round to be the future, his inconsistent performances and injuries have raised serious doubts about his long-term potential. The Mitch Trubisky experiment failed, and Mason Rudolph is nothing more than a stopgap solution.

With a playoff-caliber defense and talented offensive weapons like George Pickens and Najee Harris, Pittsburgh needs a true difference-maker under center. And according to sources, that’s why the front office is seriously considering an Ohio State star quarterback in the upcoming draft or through an unexpected trade.

Is an Ohio State QB the Answer? Steelers Fans Are Divided

Historically, Ohio State quarterbacks have struggled to find success in the NFL. From Dwayne Haskins (RIP) to Cardale Jones and J.T. Barrett, the track record isn’t exactly inspiring. Even Justin Fields, who was once hyped as the next superstar, has yet to fully establish himself as a top-tier NFL passer.

This raises the biggest question: Would an Ohio State QB really work in Pittsburgh, or would it be another draft bust waiting to happen?

Some analysts believe the “Ohio State QB curse” is a myth. They argue that the Buckeyes’ recent signal-callers, like C.J. Stroud, have already shattered that narrative. If the Steelers truly believe in the talent of a top OSU quarterback, they should make the move—no matter the past failures.

Steelers’ Draft vs. Trade Dilemma: Which Route Makes Sense?

If the Steelers decide to go after an Ohio State quarterback, they have two options:

1. Draft a QB in 2024 – If a top Ohio State prospect (like Kyle McCord or Devin Brown) impresses in workouts and pre-draft evaluations, Pittsburgh could use an early-round pick to secure its next franchise QB. However, do the Steelers really want to risk another young, unproven signal-caller?
2. Make a Surprise Trade for Justin Fields – If the Chicago Bears decide to move on from Fields and draft Caleb Williams, the Steelers could strike a deal to bring Fields back to his home state of Pennsylvania. Fields has shown flashes of brilliance but has struggled in Chicago’s dysfunctional system. Could a fresh start in Pittsburgh unlock his full potential?

Both options carry significant risks. A draft pick is a gamble, and Fields could prove to be just another overhyped Ohio State quarterback who fails to transition to the NFL.

Is Mike Tomlin Willing to Take a Risk?

One of the biggest factors in this decision is head coach Mike Tomlin. Known for his loyalty to his players, Tomlin may hesitate to give up on Kenny Pickett just yet. However, if he believes an Ohio State QB is a true upgrade, he has to be willing to make the tough call.

The Steelers’ Super Bowl window won’t stay open forever. The defense is elite, and the AFC North is only getting tougher. If Pittsburgh wants to compete with teams like the Ravens, Bengals, and Browns, they can’t afford to waste time with mediocrity at quarterback.

Final Verdict: Should the Steelers Target an Ohio State QB?

This move could either be a franchise-defining steal or a historic failure. The Steelers must decide if they are willing to break the “Ohio State QB curse” and invest in a Buckeye signal-caller.

Would you want the Steelers to draft an Ohio State QB or trade for Justin Fields? Is this the right move—or a disaster waiting to happen? Let us know in the comments!