---

In a move that has sparked heated debate among college football fans, former Notre Dame center Pat Coogan has committed to Indiana, leaving many Fighting Irish supporters stunned. The decision comes after Coogan entered the transfer portal, seeking a fresh start after spending three seasons in South Bend. But why Indiana? And what does this mean for both programs?

A Surprising Transfer Choice

Pat Coogan, a 6-foot-5, 305-pound offensive lineman, was expected to have several suitors after entering the transfer portal. Many assumed he would land at another top-tier program, perhaps even within the SEC or Big Ten powerhouses. Instead, he chose Indiana—a program that has struggled in recent seasons and recently hired Curt Cignetti as head coach to spark a turnaround.

This decision has raised eyebrows, with some fans calling it a step down for Coogan. After all, going from Notre Dame, a perennial College Football Playoff contender, to Indiana, a team that finished 3-9 in 2023, doesn’t seem like a move for immediate success. But is there more to this decision than meets the eye?

Why Coogan Picked Indiana

Despite the initial shock, there are logical reasons for Coogan’s choice:

1. Playing Time & Role
   At Notre Dame, Coogan was part of a deep offensive line room, battling for reps against elite talent. At Indiana, he has a chance to be a veteran leader and a full-time starter—an opportunity that may not have been as guaranteed in South Bend.
2. Reuniting with Familiar Faces
   Indiana’s coaching staff has strong ties to Notre Dame and the Midwest. Cignetti is aggressively revamping the roster, and landing a proven lineman like Coogan is a significant win for the Hoosiers.
3. Building Something New
   While Indiana has struggled in the past, the transfer portal era has changed the game. Coogan may see the potential for a quick rebuild under Cignetti and wants to be part of the program’s resurgence.

Notre Dame Fans React: Betrayal or Business Decision?

Some Notre Dame fans feel betrayed, questioning why Coogan would leave a program known for developing NFL-ready offensive linemen. The Fighting Irish have sent numerous linemen to the pros, and many believe staying in South Bend would have been the best path for his career.

Others argue that Notre Dame’s depth chart and recruiting pipeline may have pushed Coogan out. With high-profile talent coming in, perhaps he saw the writing on the wall and chose to take control of his own destiny.

What This Means for Indiana Football

For Indiana, this is a huge win. Landing a former Notre Dame offensive lineman brings instant credibility to Cignetti’s vision. If Indiana can continue to pull talent from major programs, they might be on the fast track to competitiveness in the new-look Big Ten.

Final Verdict: Smart Move or Mistake?

Only time will tell whether Coogan’s move to Indiana will pay off. If he becomes a key leader on the Hoosiers’ offensive line and helps turn the program around, it could be seen as a brilliant career move. But if Indiana continues to struggle, some might argue that he left a golden opportunity at Notre Dame for a less competitive program.

One thing is for sure: Pat Coogan’s transfer is one of the most surprising moves of the offseason, and the football world will be watching closely to see how it plays out.

Do you think Coogan made the right decision? Let us know in the comments!