The Indianapolis Colts may have found their potential franchise quarterback in Anthony Richardson, but is he really their long-term answer? Despite the high expectations placed on the young signal-caller, the Colts’ front office isn’t blind to the looming uncertainties surrounding his future. With concerns over his durability and passing consistency, Indianapolis could be eyeing fresh competition at the quarterback position sooner than fans expect.

Injuries and Inconsistencies: Red Flags for Richardson?

When the Colts selected Richardson with the fourth overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft, they gambled on his immense physical talent rather than his experience or refined quarterback play. While Richardson’s athleticism and arm strength make him an exciting dual-threat player, his limited college starts and raw mechanics have led to questions about his development.

Moreover, his early NFL career has been plagued by injuries, raising doubts about his ability to withstand the physical toll of the league. If Richardson continues to struggle with durability issues, the Colts may have no choice but to explore other options at quarterback—either through the draft, free agency, or a potential trade.

The Colts’ Front Office Remains Open-Minded

Indianapolis has shown in the past that they won’t hesitate to make bold moves at the quarterback position. After Andrew Luck’s sudden retirement, the franchise cycled through a revolving door of short-term solutions, including Jacoby Brissett, Philip Rivers, Carson Wentz, and Matt Ryan. While the Colts are giving Richardson every opportunity to succeed, history suggests that patience only lasts so long in the NFL.

If a promising quarterback prospect emerges in the draft or a veteran with a proven track record becomes available, the Colts could strongly consider bringing in legitimate competition. That’s not to say they’ll completely abandon Richardson, but rather, they may want a contingency plan in place.

Who Could Challenge Richardson?

Several intriguing names could be in play should the Colts decide to add competition at quarterback. If they opt for a veteran presence, someone like Kirk Cousins, who still has a few solid years left, could provide stability. On the other hand, if they look to the draft, prospects like Caleb Williams, Drake Maye, or another young talent could be on their radar—especially if Richardson’s development stalls.

Another scenario could involve a mid-level veteran who can push Richardson in training camp and serve as an insurance policy in case injuries persist. Gardner Minshew provided that role in 2023, but the Colts could seek an even more established presence.

Richardson’s Response: Prove It or Lose It

For now, the starting job is Richardson’s to lose, but the message is clear—he needs to show he can stay healthy and take major strides as a passer. The Colts are committed to building around him, but they won’t blindly tie their future to one player if warning signs persist.

Richardson has all the tools to be a franchise quarterback, but in today’s NFL, potential only gets you so far. The pressure is mounting in Indianapolis, and if Richardson doesn’t take control of his own destiny, the Colts may be forced to explore their options sooner than anyone expected.