The Dallas Cowboys’ 2024 season has been a rollercoaster, with their running back (RB) corps at the center of both praise and scrutiny. Rico Dowdle, in particular, has emerged as a standout performer, leading to calls for commendation. However, it’s crucial to temper expectations and consider the broader context of the team’s performance.

Rico Dowdle’s Ascendancy

Rico Dowdle’s journey from an undrafted free agent to the Cowboys’ lead running back is nothing short of remarkable. After re-signing with the team in March 2024, he seized the opportunity to step up, especially following Tony Pollard’s departure to the Tennessee Titans. Dowdle’s performance has been noteworthy, with back-to-back games exceeding 100 rushing yards and consistent double-digit fantasy points in PPR formats. His ability to exploit defenses, particularly against teams with vulnerable run defenses like the Carolina Panthers, has been a bright spot in an otherwise challenging season. 

Ezekiel Elliott’s Return and Struggles

The Cowboys made headlines by bringing back veteran running back Ezekiel Elliott on a one-year deal. Once a dominant force in the NFL, Elliott’s return was met with mixed reactions. Unfortunately, his performance has not lived up to expectations. Averaging a career-low 3.1 yards per carry and facing disciplinary issues that led to him being left out of a game against the Atlanta Falcons, Elliott’s return has been underwhelming. This has placed additional pressure on quarterback Dak Prescott and raised questions about the decision-making of the Cowboys’ front office. 

The Committee Approach

Head coach Mike McCarthy has emphasized a running back-by-committee approach for the 2024 season. This strategy aimed to distribute the workload among Dowdle, Elliott, and other backs like Dalvin Cook. However, the execution has been inconsistent. While Dowdle has shined, Cook’s contributions have been limited, and Elliott’s struggles have been well-documented. The lack of a clear RB1 has led to unpredictability in the running game, affecting the overall offensive rhythm. 

Team Performance and Playoff Hopes

Despite individual successes, the Cowboys’ overall performance has been disappointing. With a 6-8 record, their playoff hopes are slim. The inconsistency in the running game, coupled with defensive lapses, has contributed to this underperformance. The team’s reliance on veteran players returning to form has not yielded the desired results, prompting criticism of the front office’s offseason decisions. 

Tempering Expectations

While it’s tempting to laud Dowdle’s individual achievements, it’s essential to consider them within the team’s broader struggles. Football is a team sport, and individual accolades mean little without team success. The Cowboys’ offensive line has faced challenges, and the passing game has been inconsistent, further complicating the running backs’ effectiveness. Moreover, the committee approach has led to a lack of rhythm and continuity in the backfield.

Looking Ahead

As the season progresses, the Cowboys must reassess their offensive strategies. Committing to a lead back, whether it’s Dowdle or another player, could provide the stability needed to revitalize the running game. Additionally, addressing offensive line issues and fostering better team chemistry are crucial steps toward improvement. The front office should also reflect on their offseason decisions, particularly the reliance on veteran players whose best years may be behind them.

Conclusion

Rico Dowdle’s recent performances are deserving of recognition, but it’s imperative to maintain realistic expectations. The Cowboys’ challenges run deeper than the running back position, and addressing these systemic issues is vital for future success. Applauding individual efforts is warranted, but only when they contribute to the team’s ultimate goal: winning.